Download the FREE ⌚️ WatchSmarts Beginner Buyer's Guide
Oct. 27, 2026

030: Ben's Watch Club with Ben Arthur

030: Ben's Watch Club with Ben Arthur
WatchSmarts
030: Ben's Watch Club with Ben Arthur

Get the FREE WatchSmarts Beginner Buyer's Guide

David interviews Ben Arthur of Ben's Watch Club, In The Loop, and the In The Loop newsletter about building a trusted voice in affordable watches and why the hobby doesn't require luxury spending. Ben explains how he pivoted from menswear content after receiving fashion watches, then started making honest reviews in response to "suspect" influencer coverage; he also briefly ran a one-to-one YouTube coaching business before focusing fully on his watch channels. They discuss the hard work behind channel growth, the motivational impact of a WatchCrunch "love letter," and why a follow-up Spaghetti Scametti parody watch is unlikely. Ben says he owns few luxury watches, critiques low-quality offerings from brands like Sekonda and Fossil, argues Seiko is moving upmarket via discontinuations and scarcity marketing, outlines when limited editions feel justified, and describes how Chinese brands evolved from clones to more original designs, with microbrand highlights like Vaer, Nezumi, Zelos, and Merkur. He closes with advice to avoid debt and ignore pressure to "level up" to Rolex, emphasizing that great watches exist at lower prices.

==========
FREE GUIDE: Buy Your First Great Watch Without Getting Burned

Download the WatchSmarts Beginner Buyer's Guide »

0:00 Ben: Don't go broke buying watches or don't plunge into debt buying something as insignificant as a watch. Right? I, I know that we like to talk about them online and, and they can be fun to watch videos about and stuff like that, but yeah. Do not go crazy buying watches. That's something that, you know, if I thought that most of my viewers were firing into debt just to hoard watches, I would be pretty sad about it, so please don't do that. David: Welcome to WatchSmarts, where smart people get smarter about watches. I'm your host, David Newman. Let's jump right in.

0:44 People say, "You know, watches, that's a terribly expensive hobby. Gosh, you know, you must have to spend thousands and thousands and thousands of dollars to get into watches." Well, my next guest says that is absolutely not the case, and you can have a fantastic time and an amazing collection with affordable watches. And he knows this because he does this, and he teaches this to millions of people every month. It's Mr. Ben Arthur from Ben's Watch Club, and of course, the In The Loop reviews, and, uh, newsletter and YouTube channel, and all kinds of amazing things. Ben Arthur, welcome to the show. Ben: Thank you, David. Yeah, wonderful to be here. When you say, you know, not spending thousands, I guess it's a matter of perspective though, isn't it really?

1:27 Because it's one of these things where you go into it not wanting to spend thousands, but all your small purchases stack up over the years, don't they? So I guess technically, uh, you might still be in the red in the end. David: Well, you totally caught me. In fact, it's not only, not only could it add up to thousands over the years, it could add up to thousands over the months. Ben: Yeah, potentially. Yeah, David: yeah. In some cases, you go, "Oh, this is great, it's only $300. Oh, this one's amazing, it's only $500. This one's amazing, it's only 150." And then off we go. Off we go to crazy town. That's Ben: it, yeah. David: Well, as we're getting rolling, I would love you to share a little bit about your professional journey that brought you to the current work that you're doing today, and what were some of the pit stops and detours along the way?

2:12 Ben: Oh, absolutely, yeah. I mean, we were having a, a little bit of a, a quick chat about this in the, uh, pre-lobby, weren't we, a little bit? Yes. But, um, yeah, my story's a little bit different than the majority you might have on your show because my watch journey really started with topics completely unrelated to watches. So I, you may have seen online, I had a, uh, YouTube channel that I started back in 2016, I think it was, based on, uh, men's style and menswear. As you might imagine, there is, like, a small, uh, crossover between, uh, watches and menswear in a sense. And, um- Yeah … it got to the point where after enough videos, some of these watch brands, especially some of the, uh, bit more questionable fashion watch brands, wanted to start sending me products, right, um, to promote a- and shill or whatever you want to call it- Yes uh, to, to get some, some revenue for them.

3:02 So they started sending me some watches. Ended up getting my hands on, on quite a few watches, uh, rather quickly. And, uh, and it was then that I kind of explored online to see what else was out there about watches. It was one of these things, I'd got all these watches in my hands, it just inherently made me more interested about watches in general. And I was looking for some of the more nerdy stuff. I've always been someone who likes to, to compare things, get the best things for money. Um, when you grow up in a bit more of, like, a, a modest or humble background, it's one of these things that you find yourself doing inherently anyway. So- David: Yeah … Ben: I started exploring online and, uh, I don't know, to be, to be honest, I just started seeing some extremely, um, suspect videos, shall we say, from some of these, uh, influencers who were, uh, saying universally good things about anything that was said.

3:52 And- David: Yeah … Ben: my whole career kind of started from there really. I, uh, decided, you know what, I'm, I'm not gonna be one of these people who is basically a salesman for the watch industry, if I can help it, anyway. I wanna start making videos, whether that be reviews, unboxings, whatever, uh, that people can, can trust and rely on, where I will be telling the truth. And it, it started from there really. David: Now, along the way, between starting the, um- What you were doing in 2016, I'm guessing that this caught on to a level where people were coming to you and going, "Hey, Ben, you have all this social media following. You have all this YouTube stuff figured out.

4:33 Can you teach me? Can you teach me? Can you teach my company?" And talk about Social Boost for a moment. Ben: Oh, yeah, sure. So there was a one point where, I don't know, I just thought I might have a good opportunity to, to do something quite easy on the side because I've always enjoyed helping other people with stuff. My wife says to my own detriment a lot of the time because I end up doing too much of it for free. But, um, yeah, I saw an opportunity where I could maybe have it as somewhat of a paid hobby, basically. So at one point I set up a, uh, like a one-to-one kinda coaching business. So had a few people, I think I m- must have had two to three clients where they, they would come to me, ask me questions about their channel.

5:14 We'd review it every so often. I'd give my thoughts as to why they maybe weren't succeeding or, or hadn't made it, shall we say- Yeah … on YouTube. Um, which is a incredibly difficult thing to do, it turns out. And, um, yeah, I, I'd give them all my input and, you know, put the own- onus on them then to, to put my words into action, really. So- Yeah … that was fun. It, it, it really got to the stage, to be honest though, David, where we ended up expanding the Ben's Watch Club business so much that that just got pushed back onto the sidelines, and then I ultimately ended up selling the domain and, and ditching it 'cause I didn't have the time anymore. David: Yeah. Amazing. Well, just so people have the context, a lot of people build up one channel to a just respectable level and say, "Look at me. I know what I'm doing, and here, you know, here we go." You've done this three times.

6:02 I'm guessing you can do this as many more times as you like because the Ben Arthur channel has 127,000 subscribers. Uh, the main Ben's Watch Club, as we're recording this, I'm sure it's more hundreds or thousands every day, but it's right now 283,000 on Ben's Watch Club. And then there's another 58,500 on In The Loop, which is specifically the unboxing and the reviews. What would you say Besides being a really respected voice in the industry, you know, being one of the good guys, so to speak, so the content is excellent.

6:43 There's a lot of people putting excellent content out there that do not have 283,000 subscribers, do not have 58,000, 127,000. What have you found to be the secret beyond having really great content that's well thought out, carefully curated, well shot, well presented? Is there anything else that's kind of like the keys to the kingdom? Ben: It's funny you should say that. I, I was anticipating you might ask me something along those lines. And, uh, the truth of the matter, David, is I'm not sure there particularly is a, a secret. I, I think the closest thing to a secret that you can get is I think some people are kind of inherently made for this as a job, if you know what I mean.

7:24 Mm. Their skill sets from when they were young, you know, through school and stuff, how they've developed as a person just inherently suits an online presence in a way. You've got that baked in charisma, or you- Yeah … you can just explain things better. I think that's one inherent advantage that unfortunately seems very difficult to kind of teach or to learn if you're not someone who has it. Coming from a performing arts background to some extent, that was something that was drilled into me from a fairly young age. But yeah, I think the only other secret is that there really isn't any other secret. Like, it is just tremendously hard work, years of slaving away earning pittance and trying to constantly reevaluate your business, 'cause that's how this whole thing is run, by the way.

8:13 All these YouTubers that you see there with big followings all run this thing like a business because it's the only way to, to get by. Otherwise, you, you will be, uh, very poor, especially when it comes to watches, which- Right … cost an arm and a leg to purchase for every video. David: Right. Quick commercial break here to ask you, have you seen all of the cool resources, downloads, and guides waiting for you at watchsmarts.com? Go check it out. You'll love it Well, I do wanna dig in a little bit to Ben's Watch Club and what you're doing with the newsletter, and then I'd also love to talk a little bit about your own collection. Yeah. But in preparation for our chat today, and I, I know you know this, it's not a surprise.

8:54 I was kind of bummed out that you know about this, but that's okay. You and I are both members of a community called Watch Crunch, and about a year ago, there was a love letter by one of the Watch Crunch members to Ben Arthur. And I just happened to come across it, and then in the comments, you know, 'cause he tagged you, and I'm not sure how often you were on there at the time, but it was this love letter. I just wanna read a couple of lines, if I may, that really jumped out at me that speak to your integrity, your impact, the, the influence that you have over the regular, everyday watch fan, watch aficionado, beginning collector, what have you.

9:36 Would it be okay if I do that? Ben: Oh, sure, David. I, I think I've started blushing already here. This is wonderful. David: So, so this is, again, it's watchcrunch.com, which is a great community, and there's … I know there's many communities online and Facebook groups and so forth. But this person just, you know, unknowing that Ben would ever see this initially, wrote this post for the rest of us going, "Hey, if you don't know about Ben, here's what I think about Ben." It says, "He has methodically and single-handedly exposed and did takedowns of entire, uh, shady fashion watch brands, all while teaching the rest of us in that razor-sharp, well-articulated manner," that I'm assuming most of us are familiar with.

10:23 He says that you are, you know, systematic and thorough and integrity. "His research, documentaries, and in-depth reviews have done so much for consumer awareness, going well beyond mere consumer advocacy, and made a huge dent and a lasting impact in the world of horology." I'll just read one more. I mean, you could read the whole thing and it would be amazing. But, "Ben's unique approach, blending passion with expertise, has given us the tools to make informed decisions, helped to steer us away from flashy, overpriced watches, and towards pieces that truly reflect the artistry and precision behind watchmaking, that embody the very essence of horology instead of the fleeting trends of the fashion world.

11:14 In conclusion, the impact Ben Arthur's YouTube channel, Ben's Watch Club, has had on me and the watch enthusiast community as a whole is tremendous. Even if there's only a million hardcore watch enthusiasts in the world that have benefited from Ben's hard work, his contribution is still significant." I'm not sure how a million could be less than significant. But he goes on and on and on. A- and then the, the lovely part of this to me He says, "In conclusion, I highly doubt Ben's eyes will ever come across this essay, but if it does, I just wanna say, Ben, I cannot thank you enough for all the effort and hard work you put into keeping us informed, and I hope for you and your loved ones spiritual and worldly success, as well as some more watches that'll actually fit your tiny six-and-a-quarter inch wrists."

12:08 And, uh, that is signed by our colleague Abdullah Al Salafi in the WatchCrunch community. Long-winded way of saying, number one, you're awesome. The lead into the question is, when you read that about a year ago, how did that make you feel? What, what were the thoughts that bubbled up for you? Ben: Oh, fantastic, David. I mean, it's those sorts of messages, to be honest, that have kept me doing this for as long as I have, because it's one of these careers that, uh, it can be tremendously high pressure. You are constantly at the beck and call of the algorithm, if you know what I mean. You're, you're- David: Yeah … Ben: at the point of the sword, and there's been many a time when I- I'm considered packing this up and returning to a, a more stable, predictable job, even if it was- Yeah more boring.

12:57 And yeah, seeing messages, uh, uh, as kind, I'm, I'm sure that guy is by far overstating my impact. But, you know, seeing these, these lovely, heartwarming messages, and I do get some along those lines via email occasionally too. It certainly builds that confidence back up, 'cause, uh, I have had some extremely hard times behind the scenes the last few years, not specifically to do with the YouTube stuff, been off-platform stuff. And, um- Sure … some of these messages came at ev- actually quite important times for me to, to really give myself some fortitude back. And, uh, so yeah, massive plaudits to the gentleman behind that message because, uh, yeah, it takes something to put a message like that out there, full stop.

13:37 And it, it was cool to be able to actually read it for myself, you know? Uh, yeah, yeah, it was great. David: It really was. It really was. It's funny, in, in, m- uh, my day job, 'cause this is really my little hobby, at least right now it's a, a hobby. It's th- getting some nice traction, but it's, it's not my… It's not, doesn't make any money. Uh, but in my main business that does make money, I will occasionally get messages like that, either a Facebook post or an email or a text or something, and it almost always comes at a time that I desperately and seriously need to hear that. It always comes at some sort of low moment Or a period of self-doubt or, or imposter syndrome.

14:20 No matter what the accolades, no matter how many subscribers, no matter what the, the appearance of success, right? We all have that little gremlin, the imposter syndrome. You know, am I good enough? Is this worth keeping going? And, uh, I will say that in my experience, those messages come at always the right time. It's like the magic of the universe at work. Ben: Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, I, it does make me, uh, uh, believe in magic at times like that, for sure. Yeah. So yeah, I, I… It's great to hear that any- anyone, you know, say that sort of thing about me, but, uh, yeah. David: Yeah. Ben: It's cool. David: Well, moving, moving from the profound to the ridiculous, I did ask our WatchCrunch community, uh, if they have some questions for you.

15:04 And so there's only three or four questions that I'll select from the, the submissions, but I do want to… My, the first question is very, very important. People will need to research this online. You'll need to do some YouTube searches. First question from the community that they wanted me to specifically ask you: Will there be a resurgence in demand for a new Spaghetti Scametti model? Ben: Uh, so the tricky part here, David, is I would love to say yes, right? So, so for those listening, Spaghetti Skimetti was my attempt at basically a parody watch brand to take the Michael out of all of these big watch brands and some of the, the blunders they make, some of the weird models they release.

15:48 And my idea all along was every time one of these pops up, so whether it would've been the, the MoonSwatch or something- Oh, yeah … we do our own stupid version of it, essentially, just for pure comedic value, make it relatively affordable so people could actually afford one. Uh, and then just have, uh, some hilarious adverts to go along with it. And while the first Spaghetti Skimetti did okay, um, we, we did eventually sell out of the units. I think we had 520 units or something. Uh, we did eventually sell w- out within a year, which was good, but I don't know, it financially made no sense to kind of continue. It was so much time spent on all this stupid stuff, but we, we figured it was worth a go, right?

16:30 We figured, uh, you know, this might be the next, uh, big meme brand that people catch onto and, and just would love it. We would, we would love to have continued it, but, uh, unfortunately it looks like limited edition really actually did mean limited edition in hindsight. David: Yes, it did. Another question from the community: have you ever been asked to review a watch or, or just decided to re- because I, I know that you don't take sponsors, you don't, you know, you don't take any free stuff. It's all you. It's like, it's … You're the Consumer Reports of the, uh, which is a magazine in the US, uh, that is completely unbiased product, um, re- reviews, ratings, et cetera. So the question is maybe phrased in a bit of a strange way.

17:10 It's not have you ever been asked, but have you ever reviewed, let's say. Have you ever reviewed a watch, and after opening the box, realizing it's a piece of crap, film the episode, and then decide to scrap the episode because the product is so terrible? Ben: Uh, yeah, yeah. There's been a few times. To be honest, most of those were quite a few years ago when I wasn't quite on point with my judgments about watches, essentially. Yeah. I think the thing nowadays is my, my nose is so well-tuned to sniffing out what's gonna be good and what's not that that is extremely rare, where I receive a watch, open it, and it turns out to be junk But yeah, like I said, going back a few years, that wasn't quite the case yet.

17:53 Uh, I was still relatively new to the hobby. Yeah. And there was certainly many, many watches that would eventually end up having to be s- resold on eBay because I never got around to covering them because they were, were trash. Some of these are from brands that I've kind of covered more recently in a couple of recent videos. So I think my most recent Ben's Watch Club video at the time of recording this was 10 famous watches I wouldn't buy in 2026 anymore. That's David: right, Ben: yeah. Uh, and a couple of the brands on there were from … included Sekonda from the UK or Fossil from the US, many of whose current offerings are just unfortunately, in my opinion, complete trash, like, in terms of how they're built. Yeah. Uh, and there was definitely a couple from those brands, for example, where I received them and just thought, "Nah, nah, I've given this brand many chances at this point.

18:41 It turns up, it looks below what I would consider, like, a minimum viable watch. Like, I'd rather not wear anything than wear this." Um- Right … so there was a couple of those. Uh, although some of the more comedic videos I've done in the past probably were unboxing some of those examples. So for instance, there was one where I bought incredibly suspect, not sure I'm allowed to say scam, but there was an incredibly suspect watch that arrived from a company called Filippo Loreti, which, uh, took many months to arrive. And then after I expo- did an expose style video, it suddenly arrived at my door, right? Uh, so I did an unboxing video on that, and that ended up, yeah, I ended up slating it quite a bit.

19:23 Not- Yeah … unequivocally, but it w- it was, yeah, not great for sure, and that one ended up featuring, so there has been a few. Yeah. Yeah. David: And then the final question from the community, then we'll get back to talking about other things, other fun things. Ben always reviews budget/affordable watches, but does he have any luxury watches in his own collection? And if so, what are they? Ben: Not really, no. That's, that's the truth of the matter. Um, I think the, the closest I've got, I have got a, a Christopher Ward C63 Sealander GMT, which they sent for a video ages ago. Yeah. Um, that's the only one that would, would probably qualify as luxury, to be honest.

20:04 Yeah, I really am someone who thoroughly kind of does as he says o- on the videos. Right. Like, I, I'm literally wearing a nice Timex E-Line. It looks luxury- Oh … but unfortunately, yeah, it, it isn't. Yeah. But yeah, I, I've just never really been bothered by spending over 1,000 pounds on a watch. Like, for me personally, I'd rather spend it on my cats or something, I think. David: I do wanna talk a little bit about some specific brands that I think you love and respect, and as do I, and the first one is Seiko. Seiko has such a fantastic catalog, back catalog, history with affordable watches, dive watches, all kinds of fun colors and innovations, and all kinds of things.

20:48 The one thing I wanna ask you about what your feelings are about this around Seiko, they have this really crazy habit of taking a watch that is selling like hotcakes, I mean, selling like crazy And discontinuing it. And so just this, uh, this month or in the last few months, the Seiko Slim Willard SPB317, that's going bye-bye as we speak. The ADs still have some if people wanna get one, but it's rapidly disappearing. June 1st, they, uh, discontinued the Prospex Speedtimer Pogue, which is, you know, the gold yellow one.

21:30 Yeah. SSC947, I believe. The- I'm way too into this. It's a problem. I can just quote these- You're doing well with the code names … Seiko model numbers. Yeah. So what is up with, uh … T- the pattern to me seems to be, and again, I'm just, I'm just a collector, I'm just a layperson in this. Discontinue the watch, wait a period of time, reissue an extremely similar watch, mess up one design component, and jack up the price. And this is best-selling watches that are moving, you know, tens of thousands of units every month, and they go, "Nope, that's enough. We're done." Why do they do that?

22:11 What's your take on that? Ben: So me, personally, I, I'm pretty sure it's, it's rather simple, Occam's razor style. I, I personally believe that brands like Seiko have seen the threat coming from some of these Chinese brands or some of these Japanese brands from, you know, a little bit before them, but particularly this latest generation of the Chinese brands, and thought to themselves, "Look, we can't compete with these guys in terms of bang for the buck, in terms of materials for the money. Why are we even trying to compete with them? Let's just take ourselves out of that environment entirely and target an entirely different consumer." So I think the days of Seiko being an every man's watch are, if they're not over already, they're certainly gonna be over very soon.

22:55 They have so few lower-priced offerings now that I rarely cover them. I, I still check their site for my newsletter every fortnight, but, uh, it's rare that I find anything that's under 1,000 pounds. And I'm sure that's the reason, yeah, they're, they're just using that strategy, as you said, discontinue, reissue at a higher price, to try and play in a different ballpark, to try and become more of a status symbol brand as opposed to an every man brand. Um, yeah, they, they must feel threatened in some way. That, that's how I see it. David: Yeah, it's really crazy. I mean, one of the things, uh, and this also has to do with limited editions and special editions and things like this, so, but by the time this episode airs, the, uh, I believe we are gonna have the 145th anniversary Seiko, uh, Edo purple editions of some of these watches.

23:50 Uh, one or two I think are in the 4 to $600 price range. The rest are in crazy town. What do you think of these special editions, limited editions? Not just necessarily Seiko, but a lot of brands are doing it. Timex does it, Casio does it, all of them do it. Uh, what's the deal with that, and do you feel it's worth jumping on some of these just for collector value? Ben: So the reason that they're doing it obviously is because, uh, they're just trying to create scarcity marketing blatantly as well. They're not even trying to disguise it. Um, they're, they're just purely going for the, uh, the scarcity marketing tactics. Is it, uh, Robert Cialdini, is it? The, the Art of Persuasion i- it's one of the main factors in that book.

24:32 David: Yes. Ben: And, um, yeah, that, they're just going all in on that one, basically. Yeah. And the way I see it personally is I've got no problem if the limited edition watch is doing something that's truly unique, special, has extra features, has a really solid reason for it being a limited edition, or if it is celebrating something that deserves celebrating. The trouble with certain brands, like Seiko for example, is that none of those things really apply. So for example, with these most recent purple ones, their justification in the first place for the special edition is the 145th anniversary. So I mean, that's quite a niche number for starters.

25:14 It, you know, I can understand particularly 150th Even if you wanted to stretch it every 10 years, maybe doing things that are special- Yeah uh, you could really plan ahead then and do a really good job of it, couldn't you? But every five years? I mean, what's it gonna get to soon? Are they gonna be celebrating, like I said in the newsletter, 146th next time? I mean- That's right. I love that line … it's really stretching things. Yeah. It's, it's, it's really stretching things at this point. But also, then you look at the way they've executed it, and they're just literally turning some of their existing watches purple. That's it. They've just colored them purple. David: Yeah. Ben: And, you know, a few years ago we would've just said, "Oh, look, it's arrived in a new color." Whereas now, no, this is being pushed as a limited edition, and even then, e- when you look at the limited edition, some of them limited to 10,000 units.

25:59 Like, that would just have been called a, a normal production run back in the day. So- Right … yeah, some of it is just the way it's being pitched as opposed to anything else, because they, they know that by just changing the, the wording and changing the way they're pitching it, they might be able to get, you know, a higher click-through rate or higher- Right higher purchase rate. So yeah, they're the ones that I've really got a problem with. Some other brands, for example, Zelos do a better example of this, because they may be limited edition, but the ones that are limited edition come with entirely different dials, completely random materials, different cases. And while I don't like the majority of them, to be frank, you can see why they may have some collective value.

26:39 Whereas some of these others, when you s- ask the question of like, is it worth it if you're a collector and you just want something special, well, is what you've got really special? Is this random purple version of a watch gonna be something that you see, uh, be picked up on one of these auctioneering TV shows in 60 years' time? Probably not. Pro- they might even just mistake it for a normal version, quite frankly. So I've never been into watches as investments in the first place anyway, and I think that's kind of the way a lot of the luxury watch content online is really targeting, is just people who are after investment watches and yeah, that's never really been my thing. I like to use and abuse them David: Yes, absolutely agree with you on that for sure.

27:21 You mentioned Chinese watches, and I think for people that don't know, especially perhaps beginning collectors, Chinese watches are amazing. They're, like, great. I mean, specifically the Addies Dive, the Watch Dives, the San Martin. You know, a lot of times, th- the YouTube crowd, they say, "Hey, you know, uh, I got this watch on AliExpress for like $12, and look, it's a piece of junk." And everyone thinks Chinese watches are, number one, from AliExpress, and number two, pieces of junk. And they're not aware that there's this very, very high-quality, high engineering, beautiful finishing, quality materials, watches that you can get for 50 bucks, 60, 70, 80 bucks, less than $100.

28:14 And you compare it to something from, let's say, Seiko, uh, not all Seikos, but some Seikos. It's like the bracelet. The bracelet on the $500 Seiko is nonsense. The bracelet on this $75 Addies Dive is amazing. And th- everything about that watch is amazing, and I'm talking about just generally the brands. They have all kinds of different models. But I just- I'm starting to really fall in love with Chinese watches and, and those brands in particular. Wh- when did that become awesome, and, and when, when did they really come on your radar as worthy of attention? I know, yeah, I know you've r- reviewed some, and that's part of the conversation now.

28:55 Ben: Yeah, that really started, I think, I think we're, we're filming this in 2026. I think the first big wave of these well-built Chinese watches, especially these ones from the Chinese factory brands, which is some of those you were listing before, that really came about maybe during the early pandemic, 2020, 2021. They really started to rise to prominence. Some of these brands started reaching out to, uh, the YouTubers, like myself, for example, wanting to send us pieces. And back then it was a little bit different. So we could tell straight away that these new Chinese watch brands were incredibly well-constructed. Like, these watches had all the high-end materials, were, had better finishing, as you said, much better bracelets than some of the big brands, uh, and generally looked really good.

29:43 The only problem with them back then was they were all just clone watches, right? They all were just basically rebadged copies of existing luxury watch designs. Right. Which for a lot of people was a major turnoff. For some people, that's no problem. If they, you know, like the look of a 10,000 pound watch and don't wanna drop 10 grand, but really insist on having it, then, then yeah, that is a, the dream scenario. But if you're like me and would feel, like, somewhat fraudulent wearing one of these watches, they didn't really hit the mark in that regard. They really started getting good in terms of home brand designs more recently than that, probably from about 2024 onward, I would say. I just noticed they started creeping into my top watches of the year list gradually And, uh, yeah, some of them leading the way were the likes of San Martin, for example.

30:31 They had some unbelievable dial textures. More recently, their Jiang Hun sub-brand, which is entirely original designs as far as I can gather, uh, some of which are a bit ornate, shall we say. Yeah. But, uh, but other ones are phenomenal. And yeah, they are really now threatening the big brands, definitely. Um, you can see the sales figures in some of these AliExpress stores. As to how that will continue, I'm not 100%, because in some of these countries, like the US, for example, and we've got new legislation coming up here in the UK where they are gonna start, you know, charging big fees on imports directly from China. So whether that trend continues remains to be seen.

31:14 But as of recording this, yeah, they are better value for the most part. It's just a matter of how good the designs are. And I do think, David, that, um, one thing holding back a lot of these br- brands, well, it is the branding. The branding is absolutely atrocious on a lot of them. Yeah. And even the best ones, you know, they don't still have the, the story behind them that some of these other big brands do, and they, uh, aren't as easy to pronounce. That's probably the, uh, the crux of the issue, isn't it? David: Hey, David Newman here with a quick commercial break. Have you seen our social media channels that have video snippets from our favorite interviews? Check us out on TikTok, Instagram and YouTube. Now back to the episode.

31:56 I'm wondering, you know, it's funny, there are lots of books on watches and watch collecting and especially, you know, the big luxury brands. To my knowledge, there are not a lot of books on the affordable brands that you and I both like. For example, and I, and I haven't researched this in the last couple weeks, but in the last couple of months I have, there's no book on Timex Well, there's one book I could find on Casio, but it's G-SHOCK only. It's a beautiful coffee table book about the G-SHOCK, but not the rest of Timex. A lot of people might not even know that Timex actually is older than Rolex. And as far as the history, the significance, Timex is an amazing, amazing story.

32:38 There's no book on Seiko? Like, why is that? Like, we, we have books on all the high-end brands, and you would think, "Well, this isn't even, you know, people can afford a book on Rolex." Well, the book, Rolex book costs the same as the Seiko book or the Casio book or the Timex book. Why are there no books on our favorite brands? Ben: I suspect, you know, that it's, it's the type of person that, um, makes up the reader base, I think, of, of these books. I think the type of person that reads a Rolex book, number one, may be more organically interested because Rolex is the, the biggest watch brand, the most famous, maybe the most prestigious watch brand generally, uh, especially with the general public. The type of person that reads that book may just want to learn more about why they're in that position, why this brand has got so famous.

33:24 It's- David: Yeah … Ben: for example, maybe to some extent why there are far more books about the likes of Ferrari than there are Toyota, for for instance. You know- Yeah … maybe more people have that, you know, connection that they can observe that this brand is something special That's probably some of it. I think also maybe there is, hasn't been the person to, to write it un- until now. I think that's certainly some of it. Lots of these people who may be able to write a full book about Rolex, it may be a bit more difficult to write a full book about one of these smaller brands, and instead you, you maybe need more of a broad experience across tons of these different affordable brands. Uh, I think it's kind of hard to make a cheap watch good.

34:05 I think that's why it's so interesting as well. It can be really difficult to make a cheap watch really popular. Um- Yeah … so it w- would maybe require featuring multiple brands in one book. That may be some of it. And I also think that, in general, the type of person who might be interested or has the time to read a book about a Rolex, uh, is probably someone a bit more well off than someone who would maybe be wanting a book about Timex. Maybe that person- Right … doesn't have the, the time to sit and read books about watches quite so much, unless they're retired. So that, that's- Yeah … I'm as- I'm assuming some of those points stand probably. David: Yeah. But I'll tell you, if there's anyone listening who has a journalistic background, writing background, Ben and I would both love to read your books on Seiko and Timex and Casio and the Chinese brands, and whatever you wanna write about.

34:53 We will read it. We will read it. We will promote your book. I wanna talk to you, 'cause you mentioned about the Timex that you're wearing, and I know Timex does this and Seiko does this, these sort of historical revitalizations, right? New designs based on historically kind of fun or interesting watches. What are some of your favorites in that category, from any brand? Ben: So in recent times, absolutely it is Timex. I, I mean, the guys at Timex, I- I'm not sure what they feed the people that work there- … but it is something radioactive potentially, because they're able to, you know, access 100% of the brain when they're coming up with some of these, uh, reissues.

35:35 Right. Uh, yeah, in recent times they, they've got to be, especially in the affordable space, the number one procurer of, uh, amazing reissue watches. The E line that I've got here, this, this thing is just gorgeous and affordable. I mean, what else do you want really? In recent days, I've unboxed two variants actually that will be published soon, uh, of other ones that they've come up with. I won't spoil the details, but they look great, too. Um, and then they add some other dive style designs. You probably saw it, the Q Timex stuff, the Quartz stuff. Aesthetically brilliant. Might not be the best built watch. I don't think that they rival the, uh, the Chinese brands in terms of pure quality, let's say.

36:17 But aesthetically, top tier. Top tier for sure for the money And I'm trying to think of any other brand that, that comes close. I'm, I'm not sure there particularly is at the moment because although Casio has done a few, they've also attached borderline scalper pricing to them. So- Hmm … they're, they're not as, as tempting. I wa- wasn't gonna splash out £500 for a Casio Tron, definitely not. Um- Right … so yeah, th- they are, are the main ones in the conversation, to be honest. It feels at, at some points I like I'm becoming a Timex salesman. They've released that many good watches- Right … like genuinely. David: How about the, uh, the Seiko Recraft series? Those are sometimes 200, $250, uh, in that neighborhood, perhaps before this episode, and as soon as this episode hits, then they'll be $500 like everything else.

37:06 Any of the Recraft, uh, from Seiko catch your eye? Ben: Not particularly. I, I thought that the recent digital that they released was pretty good, the Rotacle reissue you might have seen- Oh, yeah, sure uh, with the rotating bezel. I, I quite like that one myself. Um, again, the problem was, was just price. Like, it was, in the UK, I think £550, which must be- David: Yeah … Ben: you know, well over $600. And, and for that price, you know, your eyes are really watering when you put it on your wrist. Yeah. Um, it, it is a good watch, and I do like it, but it's one of these where it's hard for someone like me to actively recommend them. Um, you know, I'm not sure that many people in the UK have got 600 quid to just throw at, at a watch, you know, with the current economy.

37:47 Right. David: Tell us a little bit, because I know you, you covered them and you've got some guides and some amazing resources on your website a- and also in the newsletter, but let's talk about micro brands for a moment, because micro brands, I think, is probably the most exciting or one of the most exciting, if not the most exciting sector of the affordable watch world. Uh, there's also expensive micro brands that are, you know, above $1,000 or £1,000. What are some of your favorite kinda greatest hits in the micro brand world as of right now? Ben: So I think the brand with the highest ceiling that I've seen, the micro brand is, is probably their watches. I think they're based out of the US. I think the, the founders- Yes … may be Canadian, uh, if I recall correctly.

38:30 But, um, yeah, they've got a tremendous ceiling on some of their dive style watches. They just ooze class in, in the flesh. They really do. And they're a really good example of this strange phenomenon that- that's been happening over the last five to 10 years whereby originally, these micro brands, when they first started hitting the scene en masse, maybe about 2012 or something, they were struggling to keep up with the big brands in terms of things like quality, quality control as well, designs, and you would always end up paying more for a micro brand than you would for an equivalently specced Seiko, for example. And gradually, as the years have gone by, that gap not only shrunk, but then reversed essentially.

39:15 So we're now in the bizarre situation where for plenty of these micro brands you can get Nicer looking designs, better materials, certainly more originality in, in what they're coming up with than the big brands now for similar sorts of money. So it, it is unusual. I, I do find myself more and more drawn to microbrands because of what they're offering. As for other ones that I like that I've covered recently, I think Nezumi watches out of Sweden are pretty interesting. Not all of them are hits, uh, but the ones that are hits are pretty good. Zelos, I mentioned earlier, has got some mixed in there. That one, again, is quite a low hit rate one for me particularly. I don't like their more chunky design language, but some of the- Yeah … stuff in there just is mesmerizing and, yeah.

40:00 I, I missed out on a bargain one recently, so I'm still bitter about that. But let me think. What else have we got? Sorry, I cover so many, you see here, David, that being asked which one is the best, it, it, it takes a lot of thought. David: I'm sure it does, absolutely Ben: I think one of the more interesting ones is also, and it's a kind of micro brand and Chinese brand name one, is Merkur watches out of China. They have some unbelievably nice designs mixed in there, some truly garish stuff as well. But s- they are capable of making unbelievably good watches with semi-custom movements in the back of them as well for really, really cheap. So they're another very interesting one.

40:40 But yeah, it really is a roll of the dice with the design team. David: Right. Absolutely. Well, we could talk for hours, which simply means that we have to have you back on the show. For right now, I'm gonna ask you two final questions. The final, final question is, where can we send people? What links should go in the show notes so they can get connected to the newsletter and the YouTube channels and all the other great things? Before we go there, though, uh, the second to last question is, what parting words of wisdom would you like to share for folks that are perhaps just getting into watches, just kind of peeking over the fence going, "You know, I have a couple watches. I'm a little bit, you know, I'm, I'm watch curious. I'm a watch lover, but not a watch collector yet"?

41:25 What are some parting words of wisdom as they start getting further into the hobby? Ben: So number one, don't go broke buying watches, or don't plunge into debt buying something as insignificant as a watch, right? I, I know that we like to talk about them online and, and they can be fun to watch videos about and stuff like that. But yeah, do not go crazy buying watches. That's something that, you know, if I thought that most of my viewers were firing into debt just to hoard watches, I would be pretty sad about it , so please don't do that. Number two, I would say also don't be convinced that you need to spend about £5,000 or £6,000 to get a watch that's actually pretty good.

42:05 So I've had a really varied experience of watches, including some of these, you know, higher end luxury watches, as you may call them. And outside of fancy movements, there, there really isn't a huge deal of difference between a watch that retails for about £4,000 than there is for one that retails for £600. There, there truly isn't a great deal of difference unless you want to get the microscope out or, or the movement as well. That's the only main differences. And at which point you can have a lot of fun at the low end of the market because you can afford to buy multiple different watches. I mean, these, it takes to make these, these Timexes. My wife, honestly, she thinks I'm having an affair with, with this Timex E line, 'cause I've got that many of them.

42:46 But yeah, you can have a great deal of fun, and don't fall for that weirdly pushed assumption online that you'll need to move on at some point, uh, or that you should be expected to then make your way up and eventually get, like, a Rolex or something. That… You just do whatever you want, really . Just, just- Yeah … just do whatever you want. And that, that's, that's my advice. David: Brilliant. Now, where can people go to get connected and stay connected to more Ben Arthur brilliance, advice, reviews, all the good stuff? Ben: Well, if you wanna learn how to style your hair, don't go on Ben's Watch Club anymore, not now that that's all been shaven off. So yeah, maybe, maybe they can look at my old channel for that. But as of right now, with the watch-related stuff, uh, you can check out my big videos, as I call them, on Ben's Watch Club.

43:32 That's where we kind of do roundup-style videos, comparison videos, things like that. Yeah, you can just type in Ben's Watch Club on YouTube. The channel that's been really popping off recently is the unboxing channel called In The Loop, where I try to just give viewers the first, like, hands-on experience of a watch on YouTube with semi-decent lighting and videography. So, uh, yeah, you can search In The Loop on YouTube. You'll find my, uh, stuff there. And I also have the newsletter to go along with that. So, the In The Loop newsletter, yeah, I'm sure it'll be in the show notes or something. You can subscribe to that, and I give you a little newsletter every two weeks, giving you a rundown of all the latest affordable watch releases in a bite-sized little package.

44:14 David: And that, I gotta say, that newsletter is so well done. I love the format. I love the, the different sections. It's almost like a, a news magazine that has a regular sort of editorial layout to it. And so, it's very easy to, uh, read and reference and keep the back issues in your newsletter file, and it's an ongoing, very valuable resource. Ben: Thanks. I appreciate it. I'm, I'm glad you're finding it useful. That was the intention when I started it up. David: Yes. Yes, yes, yes. Well, Ben Arthur, you are a rock star. I appreciate you so much. I hope to see you at a watch event at some point. Do you ever make it over the pond to some of the US watch events? Ben: Um, not as of yet, no.

44:55 I have visited the US before. It was, it was at an event, but it was many, many years ago. So, uh, perhaps at some point we can, I can write off a nice trip over to the US. David: Yes. Well, I'm, I'm just, I'm not working for them, but, you know, Windup and also WatchTime are in New York City. Very easy flight from the UK. Uh, October 16 through 18, coming right up. So, you know, I'll, the first- Never know … the first bourbon or the first Guinness is on me. Ben: Oh, I appreciate it. Thanks. David: So Ben, thank you so much for being with us. I really appreciate you. Ben: Yeah, thanks for hosting, David. I, uh, really appreciate the invite, too. David: And that wraps up another episode of WatchSmarts.

45:36 Listen, if you love this show, if you love watches, subscribe, download, leave us a rating or review on your favorite podcast platform, and check out all the free resources waiting for you at watchsmarts.com.