Download the FREE ⌚️ WatchSmarts Beginner Buyer's Guide
Sept. 22, 2026

025: The Horological Hitchhiker and the Human Side of Collecting with JD Tyler

025: The Horological Hitchhiker and the Human Side of Collecting with JD Tyler
WatchSmarts
025: The Horological Hitchhiker and the Human Side of Collecting with JD Tyler

Get the FREE WatchSmarts Beginner Buyer's Guide

David Newman welcomes JD Tyler, the creative force behind the Redhead Horology newsletter, to explore the psychological depths of watch collecting. JD shares his transition from a childhood fascinations with Scooby-Doo and Mickey Mouse to developing a "healthy" way to interact with the hobby through storytelling. He introduces a unique framework for collectors, categorizing them as horological hoarders, hunters, or hitchhikers, while admitting his own tendency to "hitchhike" by stumbling into meaningful pieces rather than chasing corporate hype. Together, they discuss the "hedonic treadmill" of high end acquisition and the "Red Bull effect" where marketing shapes our desires for watches we do not actually need. From the vintage charm of a $200 Timex Draper to the utility of a $150 Veyer field watch, JD emphasizes that a collection should be a curated reflection of one's authentic lifestyle and personal history.

⏱️ Timestamps
00:00 : The Birth of Redhead Horology

  • JD explains his desire to move away from mindless consumption toward a more human-centered watch hobby.
  • How his background in theology and religion informs his focus on the stories we attach to mechanical objects.

02:08 : Hoarders, Hunters, and Hitchhikers

  • JD breaks down his three-part framework for identifying your personal collecting style.
  • Why he identifies as a "hitchhiker" who prefers watches that cross his path organically rather than through a targeted hunt.

04:36 : The Hedonic Treadmill

  • A discussion on why hitting a milestone like buying a Rolex often fails to provide long term satisfaction.
  • Identifying the "spare moment consumption" habit of scrolling watch content while waiting in line for coffee.

07:11 : Affordable Vintage Vibes

  • Why JD recently picked up a Timex Draper to scratch the itch for a 1960s casual dress aesthetic.
  • Discussing the specs of the Draper, including its mechanical Miota movement and era-appropriate mineral crystal.

10:30 : Decor vs. Utility

  • David reveals his "office decor" trick for justifying a collection of over 100 affordable watches.
  • The psychological benefit of displaying watches in a case like fine china rather than feeling pressured to wear them all.

11:46 : Socially Acceptable Jewelry

  • Exploring the theory that watches are one of the few pieces of jewelry men feel comfortable wearing in certain cultures.
  • How the explosion of visual social media has turned horology into a massive marketing apparatus.

15:30 : Sourcing the Stories

  • JD shares his "secret sauce" for newsletters, including writing months of content in advance to maintain quality.
  • Retelling the story of Zak Brown from McLaren F1, whose racing career started by selling a pair of Cartier watches.

26:02 : Advice for New Collectors

  • Why JD believes beginners should stop chasing brands and start looking for personal meaning in their pieces.
  • A staunch defense of quartz movements and why they do not deserve the "snobbery" often found in the hobby.

33:42 : The Red Bull Effect

  • How branding can make an "objectively horrible" product successful by attaching it to an adventurous lifestyle.
  • The importance of distinguishing between the "zeitgeist" and your own actual daily preferences.
  • Your collection should be a reflection of your own life story rather than a curated catalog of corporate marketing.

==========
FREE GUIDE: Buy Your First Great Watch Without Getting Burned
Download the WatchSmarts Beginner Buyer's Guide »

  • Know exactly what matters (and what doesn’t) before you spend a dollar
  • Avoid the 10 common mistakes that cost beginners thousands
  • Find a great watch that fits your life, your style, and your budget
  • Skip the jargon, the snobbery, and the “collector nonsense”
  • Get a simple decision framework that makes buying easy and obvious

0:00 JD: I wrote something up on Watch Crunch the other day. It was like you're either a, um, horological hoarder, a horological hunter, or a hitchhiker. And I was like, "I'm a hitchhiker." I just love those kinds of things. David: Welcome to Watch Smarts, where smart people get smarter about watches. I'm your host, David Newman. Let's jump right in JD: I've kind of been writing online for six or seven years now, and then, uh, Redhead Horology is kind of my newest newsletter that I launched, and it purely came out of a desire to have a healthier way to interact with the hobby of watch collecting and being a watch enthusiast because I've been in, I've been into watches since my, since I was a little kid.

0:55 I remember my first Scooby-Doo watch. I remember getting a Mickey Mouse watch at a trip to Disney World. I remember my dad bought his first Seamaster, uh, 300. And so, so, uh, watches have always been an interest of mine, and then it kinda fell off in college and then came back around the last, you know, few years. But watch media is insane now. Like with you, there, there's Watch Crunch, which is where you and I connected. There's YouTube channels and Instagram channels. And so my hobby, my interest in watches became one of consumption. I didn't like that, and so I already was very active writing online. Loved that. So I was like, "What if I found a way to write about watches from a human angle?"

1:38 So a lot of my writing at Redhead Horology has to do with the human side of watch collecting, so the stories behind the pieces, why we're drawn to pieces, our histories with pieces, things like that. David: Take me back to before you started the newsletter What were some of the, uh, the unhealthy either consumption habits or purchasing habits? 'Cause of course we always like to buy watches and acquire watches. I think one of your articles said… Am I right that one of the early introductory articles said it's either about acquisition or consumption, and that both of those- Yeah, I think so. Yeah … were kind of the path to madness. So what, what were your acquisition and consumption habits before you started the newsletter?

2:23 JD: Yeah. I, so, uh, you might have noticed this. I, I love frameworks and I love visual things. I also love a good alliteration. So I wrote something up on Watch Crunch the other day. It was like, "You're either a, um, horological hoarder, a horological hunter, or a hitchhiker." And I was like, "I'm a hitchhiker." I just love those kinds of things. So when it comes to acquisition or consumption, some people, they're just always, you know, acquiring, acquiring new pieces, and, you know, that's really, really expensive. And some people… I know people who do that, and they have the, the bandwidth to do that, and that's great. But sometimes I worry that a lot of people who come into the hobby think, "Oh, the only way to meaningfully engage with this hobby is to just buy a lot of watches and buy a lot of really expensive watches."

3:11 And, like, I can't regularly go out and drop, you know, a couple grand on a watch. That's- Yeah … just for me personally, that's fiscally irresponsible. And then it's also this, like, hedonic treadmill of, "Oh, once I get this Speedmaster, I will have arrived. Once I get this Rolex, I will have arrived." But then you get it, and then you're like, "Okay, well, what's next?" So you're just on this treadmill of, of acquiring watches. And then the consumption piece is similar, but it's just like, you know, every… And this is… I'm more guilty of the consumption piece. Like, oh, I'm sitting in line to get coffee, or this morning I went and got a haircut, 8:30 this morning. I'm sitting there waiting on my barber, and I had to, like, mentally choose not to get my phone out, 'cause if I got my phone out, I would be scrolling Substack or looking at… You know, reading a watch newsletter or looking at Instagram.

4:02 Like, that's consumption to me is like all these spare moments, uh, are just spent on watch content or fill-in-the-blank content. And I don't think that's healthy, and I think it makes you… It makes the hobby way less enjoyable. Um, so I think those are two of the common pitfalls, uh, that we fall into. Fortunately, in my collection, I haven't actually bought a lot of my watches. Like, most of my pieces have been gifts. So as far as the acquiring goes, I, I think that hasn't been too much of an issue for me. My wife might disagree, but she's not here right now. Yeah. But it's the consumption piece that I, that I, that I can struggle with, like a lot of people David: So man, we could do an, and there's like two or three topics that you just brought up that we can do an entire show just on those two or three topics.

4:51 So we'll do a little bit, we'll have a little sampler, we'll have a little smorgasbord visiting each of these little main dishes. Um- David, you JD: have the perfect podcast voice. David: Oh, thank you. It's just, uh, the gift of nature, the gift of DNA. It's JD: great. David: Thank you. It's, it's funny that you say this, JD, because sometimes people say, "Dude, when do you turn that voice off?" It's like, I never turn it off. You can ask my wife, you can ask my kids. Th- this is what it is, you know? I believe it. I'll, I'll, I'll go into Starbucks and I'll say, "I'd like an Americano with room." And they go, "You have a great voice." And I'm like, "Okay, thank you." That's serious. Yeah. Thank you. I could have been tall, dark, and handsome, but no, great voice is what I get.

5:32 That's okay. It's okay. Life is not fair, it's all good, but thank you for the compliment. So I wanna talk about, 'cause you did bring up two or three really amazing things there. Expensive watches. People have to buy a lot of expensive watches. I personally, I own over 100 watches. I counted them. It's a problem, but I own one and only one, quote unquote, "expensive watch," and it's a Rolex and I got it back in 2015. It was a special occasion. It's a meaningful milestone. The rest of the watches, I mean, you know, people need to know brands like Timex, Seiko, Bulova, Casio.

6:16 These are great watches. You can spend 30 bucks, you can spend 50 bucks and get one of the iconic watches that people instantly recognize and they go, "Oh, I love that watch. That's a great piece. Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah." Yes, of course, you can go out and buy a Rolex Daytona if you have, you know, unlimited wealth and then the next week you buy an Omega, and the next week you buy a Patek, and the next week you buy who knows what. But you put your finger on it, right? Those people have unlimited resources and probably each one of those, what might be a lifelong, uh, dream and a lifelong purchase for you and me, f- to, to them it's like, "Oh, that's Tuesday. That's Tuesday." So there is that hedonic treadmill that you talk about.

6:57 Do affordable watches play into your landscape these days in any way? JD: As far as what David: I wear or- As far as you collecting them or- Yeah … admiring them or, you know, would you pick up like a, you know, an $80 Timex watch if the aesthetics spoke to you? JD: You know, it's funny you mentioned Timex 'cause I just bought a Timex Draper. I don't know if you've seen that one. Mm-hmm. So my, um, my wife got me a Seiko Skyliner from the '60s, um, that I've been restoring and love it, but I'm having some issues servicing the movement 'cause I like to work on these things myself.

7:38 And so I needed, n-I need… I didn't need, I really wanted something to kinda scratch the itch of the Skyliner, which is more of like a '60s kinda casual dress watch that I could wear kinda throughout the workday and stuff, um, while I was trying to fix the Skyliner. And so the Timex Draper, it's, uh, it retails for, like, 270. Timex gives out coupons like, like nobody's business, so I think I paid $220 or $30 for it. It's gonna be here in, like, a week. David: Yeah. JD: But it, it is a gorgeous s- vintage '60s-inspired design. It has a Miyota movement. For $200, it's a Miyota movement, 70-hour power reserve, uh, you know, 40-hour power reserve.

8:21 It has mineral… It even has mineral crystal, which people don't like, but if you're trying to have a '60s era kind of vibe- David: Yeah … a JD: mineral cryst… Like, they didn't have sapphire crystals back then. So, you know, that to me, I was just… I've been looking for something and I didn't wanna spend a lot, and, uh, that really scratched that itch. That's, to me, that's a very affordable, really cool piece. We'll see how I like it, but from a spec- Yeah … sheet and just looking at it, it's really great. And then one of my other favorite watches is a Mayer S7 field watch. It's like $150 watch. Yeah. I love it. Some- sometimes I'll wear it more than my Tudor Pelagos, just because, especially in the summer, it's just a perfect, perfect summer watch.

9:07 Um- Yeah … so yeah, I would say- Smaller watches like that do play a role to me, but I hesitate to buy them because I don't want to have a bunch of watches that are competing for time on my wrist. Sure. I want to have a few… A smaller collection where, um, the pieces are meaningful and I- Yeah … actually wear them all. Um, but that's just me. You know, everybody's different. David: Quick commercial break here to ask you, have you seen all of the cool resources, downloads, and guides waiting for you at watchsmarts.com? Go check it out. You'll love it. So here is my trick. Here's how I have basically deluded myself into the collection that I have.

9:51 You'll see these watches behind me. So these are, like, you know, between 30 and 100 bucks usually. A lot of eBay, a lot of, you know, used, secondhand. Uh, people say, "Well, you're not gonna wear all those watches. Like, what's wrong with you?" It's like, it's decor. It's office decor. So if you put it in a vertical- Yes case like this and you display them, it's like people display china in a china cabinet. They display… You know, if they collect Pez dispensers, they're not gonna eat Pez out of the Pez dispenser. They're gonna display the Pez dispensers or the Disney characters. But I wanna go back to this obsessive consumption, and it's a… This is a genuine question I, I don't know the answer to.

10:35 I'm only victim to this in our world, in the watch world. Let's say you're a jigsaw puzzle fan. Do you obsessively watch videos and YouTubes and look at Substack for jigsaw puzzle stuff? If you're a car enthusiast, is it as bad with cars? I think for some reason, watches… And maybe it's because it's such a vast variety of watches, right? The world is so big. Do you have other hobbies, for example, where this consumption thing is not really a problem, like cooking or anything like that? Travel? JD: Yeah, no, it's just this David: It's just this, right? What's up with that? I JD: don't know, I don't know. I don't know. Part of me wonders if some of it has to do with, generally speaking, I, I… This is all very contextual, but I think generally speaking, you know, men aren't typically known for being into jewelry, like quote, unquote.

11:28 True. Like, that, that's a stereotype that's probably… I live in the South, that's definitely true where I live. David: Yeah. JD: And I think on the one hand, watches are one of the few socially acceptable pieces of jewelry a man can wear, right? True. It's like a watch or a wedding band. David: Yeah. JD: And then secondly, I think that with the rise of like s- social media, watch- watches are such a visual thing, too, that you just have all of these content creators and all of these photographers that are just posting pictures constantly everywhere, and they have all these brands that are just pumping money into influencers that it just seems like it's exploded.

12:09 And so it's a- Yeah … visual thing. If you have all this desire for jewelry, maybe you don't even realize it as a man, but it's just kind of pent up and then the watch comes along, it's like it's socially acceptable and just you just go crazy. Right. I don't know. I have no, you know, I have no research to back that up, but it, it's, it's my working theory. But I, I do think that influencers and like Instagram and watches being a visual thing and just the amount of money that, you know, the brands are giving to marketing right now is just crazy, and I think that really shapes our desires. David: Yeah. No, you're right. You're right. It's kind of a, a cycle, right? That the, the more we consume, the more we desire.

12:51 The more we desire, the more we buy, which just fuels the machine to do round two, round three, round four. So JD, you've got several different newsletters. You said that Redhead Horology is your latest, but you've been in the newsletter business for quite a while. Tell us about how that whole Substack newsletter thing came to flourish. JD: Yeah. Well, it's funny. So Substack is a huge, huge thing now. It's growing a lot. But I remember about five years ago, it was, no one knew about it. There wasn't Substack Notes, which is essentially like a Twitter feed. It was just like a newsletter software. And I'd, up, up until that point, I'd done some writing online for different, different publications and- I really wanted to write more, and my, actually my brother, I, I distinctively remember him mentioning it to me like, "Hey, there's a Substack thing you should try."

13:46 And I was like, "No." Then he sent me an email about it, and I was like, "No." And so I owe him a lot of credit for this, but it's, 'cause eventually I was like, "Okay, I'll do it." So I started one, it was on Christian spiritual formation, and so that, that's kind of like my background, my education, my master's degree is in theology, my undergraduate degree is in religion. And so I started that one five years ago. I still write it. And then about a year and a half ago, you know, I was like, "This is great, but I have other things I wanna write about." You know, I don't wanna, you know, just kind of like watches, like, I have different interests and I like writing. So I wanted to, to write to people beyond just people in, you know, who, who are, you know, their religious affiliation is Christian.

14:28 I wanna write to more people than just that. So I launched a newsletter called The Flourishing Factory, which is stories, lessons, and frameworks to help people cultivate a flourishing life. And really the target audience there is me. Like, I think that for a long time I felt what a lot of people feel in our modern world, just distracted, disconnected from their values, don't feel like they have a lot of agency, feel like they wanna be more creative, but don't know how. I w- I share a lot of stories and frameworks and things, um, to that end to feel more aligned, less fragmented, more present, more creative. And that newsletter has really, really taken off in the last year. It's like I get annually 10,000 readers.

15:10 Monthly it's a couple thousand, and so it's just really, really been really cool to watch the traffic on that one. And that one I schedule out, you know, the secret sauce to newsletters is, well, one, write good stuff. So I take the craft of writing really seriously. I practice it, I study it, I do it a lot. Yeah. Two, you know, people all the time are like, "How can you write a newsletter every week?" But it's like I schedule things out. So I'm sche- it's a weekly newsletter that I'm, I'm writing for August and September right now, and it's- Yeah … you know, July 3rd, um, or July 2nd. Yeah, so I already kind of had that muscle. Things are scheduled out way in advance. And then the idea of Redhead Horology came along just a couple months ago actually, and I thought, "Well, dang, I wanna start w- writing about watches more," but I don't wanna just write about new releases, you know, and new specs and things like that.

16:00 I wanna write about The best part of watch collecting, which are the stories that we attach to these things. Like- David: Yeah … JD: almost every watch I wear, including the one I'm wearing right now, has a story attached to it, and everyone has a story like that. And so… And I love telling stories. I love writing stories. And so out of that kind of desire and that experience, Redhead Horology was born. And, you know, similar to my secret sauce, I have, before I even launched it, I collected stories from other people, wrote some of my own, and I, I have the first six months worth, worth of content already written. So, and the reception has been really, really incredible. David: And that's released weekly or bi-weekly?

16:41 How often is JD: it? It's, it's bi-weekly. Yeah, mm-hmm. David: So every two weeks there's something new. JD: Yep. Every two weeks there's something new. You know, yesterday I shared the story of my Tag Heuer, which actually belonged to my wife's grandfather. I found it in a box of his stuff. Uh, one of my first pieces was, there's a, a gentleman who unfortunately lost his daughter to suicide a, a couple years ago, and he really wanted a watch to remember her by. And so he wound up with his Zenith El Primero, um, that chronograph movement that was in the original Daytona. And unbeknownst to him, he loves the watch 'cause it reminds her, him of his daughter, but unbeknownst to him, you know, when I was writing this, this post about it, the actual, uh, Zenith marketing, I know you're a marketing guy, David, the Zenith marketing for the El Primero is about how it's, it's the kind of watch that connects generations.

17:39 David: Yes. JD: So one of the, one of the main marketing pieces is a guy, he's wearing the watch, the Zenith, and his daughter's little hand is, like, touching it. And I was like, man, what, what a perfect watch to remember, and this content, text for him to remember his daughter by. Um- David: Yes. JD: Oh, my God … so just stories like that. It's just incredible. David: Incr- that really, really is amazing. Where, now where do you source these stories? Or how do you connect with people who have interesting stories, um, like either in real life or online or Facebook or WatchCrunch? Or how do you, how do you keep your finger on the pulse of people that have interesting watch stories? JD: One, I have my own kind of stories, so that helps.

18:21 Start with- David: Sure … JD: start with myself. Two, um, I have friends with stories, so I'll ask them. Like, like my friend, uh, Jamie, who you should have on this podcast, um, he has an incredible story that he shared on his YouTube channel about his Rolex Submariner and the connection with his dad, and I asked him for permission to share that. I haven't published it yet, but I asked permission from him to share it. He lives where I live in Birmingham. And, um, and then there's a lot of people on Watch Crunch that I've kind of connected with or have interacted with my stuff, and I've just reached out. I'm like, "Hey, do you have a good story?" And same thing on Substack. And then sometimes there's just kind of stories and things that I've, I've, I've read along the way that, you know, I'm retelling.

19:03 Like, I, I just wrote something about Zak Brown, the CEO of McLaren F1's racing team, has this fascinating story of he went on Teenage Wheel of Fortune or something, and he won a his and hers pair of Cartier watches that he then sold to a pawn shop so he could buy his first go-kart to start cart racing. And that kind of, you know, obviously changed the tr- trajectory of his life because it got him into racing. And so I don't know that he's a watch guy, but, you know, you have the, the, the CEO of McLaren F1 Racing, really his journey into racing starts with a pair of Cartier watches when he was, like, 14 years old.

19:43 It's just a cool story, and I just randomly- Yeah … heard, heard him say it on a podcast and immediately Googled it and, and, you know, crafted a s- crafted that story into a, an article. David: I will tell you, it's funny because I was poking around just talking about Substack in general now, but also your newsletter. I was … You know, because y- I'm … I started out on the Redhead Horology site, and then of course, I click through on your name, and then there's your other newsletters. So I came across, you have a fantastic article about when to quit, right? There's the quitting article, and then later you followed up with the Jerry Seinfeld article about when he quit, which cost him personally, like, $100 million.

20:27 To quit at the top, they were gonna pay him $100 million to do another season. He said, "No, we're done. I've drawn the finish line." And the big insight on that from you was you take a lot of the stress and a lot of the heartache out of things when you draw the finish line in advance. And I thought that was- Yeah profound. I mean, I thought that was profound, profound, profound. And many other things, but, uh, those are the ones that kind of just jumped out at me and gave me a big hug through the screen. JD: Well, uh, thank you. Thank you for reading that. I- Yeah … those are older, older articles too, so even I was like, "When to quit, when to quit," and then that kind of jogged my memory. David: Right.

21:07 JD: I, I, I'm really encouraged that that was encouraging to you. And, you know, I will say just anecdotally You know, there are so many instances of people staying in positions too long. Yeah. Doing things too long, and you kind of start to stagnate, and then just, it just creates a lot of problems. So I think that, yeah, just m- deciding ahead of time, you know, when's the… what game are you playing? Or as Warren Buffett would say, "What scorecard are you using?" David: Yeah. JD: And then when's the game over? You know, if, if you start a new job, you know, okay, that's great. How do you know when, when it's over, you know? Yeah. Or at least what are the milestones where you're gonna stop, take a breath, and reevaluate, you know, things.

21:52 So- Yeah … yeah, I think knowing when to quit is really important, and knowing when not to quit. But usually people stay in things longer than they should. David: Well, getting back to watches, I wanna just ask you a little bit about your personal taste and your collection and things like that. And I guess the first way to ask is when you're out and about, what is it that makes you stop and look twice at a watch? What do you notice first, or what, what jumps out at you? JD: I'm drawn towards more kind of classic styles. Sure. I like simplicity. I dislike bulky watches. I dislike busy watches, so if the desi- if the dial is just really busy, a lot of things going on. That's why I struggle with chronographs for that reason.

22:34 If my dad is listening to this, sorry, Dad, he, he loves chronographs. But, uh, in general, I like, I like his. But in general, I kind of struggle with them, um, just 'cause there, there's just a lot going on with the dial. There is, for sure. You're involved with different things. And, um, so I'm drawn towards simplicity. I like n- I don't… I like no date. No day, no date. Yeah. Like, just simple dials. David: Also, just be- I'm also increasingly no day, no date, 'cause it's just clutter. JD: Yeah. So that, that Timex Draper I mentioned, that was the one thing is it, it actually is a day-date. David: Yeah. I JD: was like, "Oh, man, I just wish it was nothing." Like, I just wish it was- David: Yeah … JD: but you can't have w- everything you want in life, so. David: That's true. That's true. As far as beginning watch collectors, for the folks that are listening to us, and they're just… maybe they got their first kind of serious watch, or they got bit, you know, God, God bless them, they got bitten by the collecting bug, but they're early in their journey.

23:27 What is something in your experience that beginners focus on that doesn't actually matter, that they should just let go of? JD: Well, one I would say, kind of mentioned earlier, like, you don't have to spend an exorbitant amount of money to find something meaningful and enjoyable, especially with micro brands. I mean, good Lord. Uh, I'm wearing a Vejer right now, which is one of my favorite, you know, independent micro brands, and it's just- Yeah, you just don't have to spend thousands of dollars. Uh, two, similar to that, similar to that, like don't chase brand, which we all fall for, and I could talk a lot about that. But don't chase brand too much. Three, try to find something that is meaningful to you.

24:07 My friend has to go to Japan once a year for work, and he just went to Tokyo, and he was like, "You know, this is it. I'm gonna, I'm gonna get a Grand Seiko. Like, I'm gonna do it, and this is gonna be my first really nice watch." And, and that seems like I'm contradicting my first point, but it was meaningful to him. David: Yeah. JD: He works for a Japanese company. He goes to, uh, Japan once a year. Candidly, a Grand Seiko in Tokyo is cheaper than a Grand Seiko here. So that's- David: Yeah … JD: get it. And it's just meaningful to him. And then finally, I would say like, I think people get really into movements. That's just, that's not me personally. Like, if you are absolutely in love with a watch and it's a quartz watch, get, get it.

24:51 Like- David: Yeah … JD: uh, at the end of the day, it's a tool. Its function is to tell time, and it's also a piece of fashion. And if it's a good-looking watch, you're attracted to it If you're like, "Oh, it's not a quartz. I really want a mechanical watch or an automatic. I really wanna be a serious quote unquote collector." I, I just think, I don't know, there's just, there's a place for everything, and I think quartz gets a bad rap. David: Without getting you drawn back into the consumption cycle, but you, but you did mention that you are, you know, you love to consume in, i- information and you want to keep that in check. Are there good blogs or magazines or podcasts or YouTube channels, uh, that you recommend to newer folks getting into watches?

25:36 Obviously they're gonna go to Red Head Horology, 'cause they have to. They need to. They should. It's gonna be great for them. Thank you. But are there other, other media that you recognize and respect and would recommend to someone who's early in their journey? JD: Uh, well, this podcast obviously is- David: Oh, obviously … a great JD: place David: to start. Of course. Thank you. JD: Yeah, I, I think, uh, and I feel like I, I'm, I'm being a little too critical. I, I, I love, you know, there are YouTube channels that I love and I'm always watching and, you know, there is something about the written medium though that I think forces you to slow down. You know, uh, Cameron Weiss of Weiss Watches, he has a Substack, which is really cool.

26:17 Yeah. He's up in Nashville. He's his own brand. Sam Koval has The Sunday Reserve, and Sam is really putting a lot of energy and effort into it. And he talks a, it, it, it's watches and kind of like men's fashion, but he was kind enough to feature some of my writing in it a couple weeks ago. And yeah, I think his stuff is really great as well. That's great. And then, yeah, I, no, all the YouTube channels that come to mind are the usual suspects. My friend Jamie that I mentioned earlier, his channel I think is called RNG Watch, and his YouTube, his main YouTube channel is RNG Gamer. He i- it's on, like, vintage, I hope I get this right, but it's, like, vintage video games.

27:01 David: Oh, JD: sure. And he, he has like 500,000 followers or subscribers, something crazy. And then he just started a watch channel. It's growing a lot. And he's got some great stuff too. But yeah, th- th- th- that's what, that's what comes to mind. David: Hey, David Newman here with a quick commercial break. Have you seen our social media channels that have video snippets from our favorite interviews? Check us out on TikTok, Instagram and YouTube. Now back to the episode. Well, we have two pieces of business, two final pieces of business here as we're landing the plane. One is our lightning round, which is just five super quick A or B kinds of questions, and then I will ask you after that for any final thoughts or parting words of wisdom.

27:45 But are you ready for the lightning round question number one? JD: Let's do it. David: Okay. Strap or bracelet? Yes Good answer. Vintage or modern? JD: Yes. I like them all. Depends on David: what I'm wearing. Oh, this is gonna be tough. You're a tough customer. One great watch or five good ones? JD: One great watch, easily. David: Buy new or hunt for pre-owned? JD: Oh, pre-owned, 100%. David: And then I think you already answered this in our previous part of the conversation, but design-wise, loud watch or more quiet, reserved watch? JD: Oh, way more quiet. Yeah, yeah, yeah. David: Way more quiet. Excellent. That's the lightning round. You did it.

28:25 You got an A+. Totally fantastic. So JD Tyler, w- uh, final words of wisdom, any final thoughts for folks listening before we wrap up? JD: Yeah, actually, uh, one thing, actually two, two things that I think are worth sharing. I mentioned I feel like people can be hoarders. They have these massive collections. David: Yeah. JD: Um, you, you mentioned you have 100, you know, you know, to each his own. Some people are hunters, like they'll really geek out and they're like, "I'm gonna figure out what my next watch is. I'm gonna like look at all these specs-" Yes "watch all these reviews, and this is the one. It's gotta be perfect." And then I call myself, like a hitchhiker. So my collection, I just kind of stumble into watches, right?

29:07 Like I would tend towards being a hunter, but I kind of have to like take a step back and be like, I buy watches as they kind of come my way. I'm wearing this Veyrer Meridian. I love it. It was a gift from a former boss for, uh, an accomplishment and, you know, kind of came my wa- he didn't let me pick it out, but it kind of came my way. Um, my Tudor Pelagos, you know, I bought from a former client of mine, 'cause we were on a call and he saw me wearing this Veyrer and he thought it was a sub, and I was like, "No, it's not a sub." And then he was like, "Oh, I've got this Tudor that I never wear and the crystal's busted. I'll, I'll, you know, I'll sell it to you." So he sold it to me for well under market value. I had to fix it, but, you know- If I were to go to the Tudor boutique today, I wouldn't buy a Pelagos.

29:53 David: Yeah. JD: But it just kind of fell into my lap, you know, and I couldn't- You were hitchhiking pass up the opportunity. I was hitchhiking, s- so I was on the road and that… and my thumb was out, and that came up. So, you know, that's an option too for a lot of people, like, just be open. David: Yeah. JD: Look around. Things just happen. Watches just kind of come into your life. It just happens. David: Yeah. JD: And so th- that, and then another thing too is, you know, I'll say that really think through what your preferences are, and I love… You know, since you read The Flourishing Factory now, I don't think this is… This will be published in the next month or so it's scheduled, but I wrote something on Red Bull.

30:35 So yeah, Red Bull started in Thailand, I think it was Thailand, and it was kind of a popular energy drink for truck drivers to stay awake. David: Yeah. JD: And the owner of Red Bull, or he acquired it or something, wanted to expand Red Bull to kind of Europe and then eventually the US, and in all the blind taste tests everyone said it tasted like piss. Like, it, it tasted atrocious. Yes. So all the market research said, "Don't expand Red Bull. Don't sell it." And then this guy, whose name I can't remember, was like, "Well, let's do it anyways, but let's just invest heavily in the brand of Red Bull. Let's tie it as an energy drink to, you know, BMX cyclists and people racing in F1 and parachute skydivers jumping out of airplanes, and if you're cool, if you're adventurous, Red Bull's your drink."

31:25 So even though it objectively tastes horrible, it is this multi-billion dollar brand because it's been attached to the kind of person you wanna be, which is like marketing 101. David: Yeah. JD: But that's what's happening with watches, too. You know, I remember when the new Longines, uh, the new Hydroconquest came out, like, uh, two or three months ago, which is a killer watch, by the way. So I'm not hating on, on them at all. But all of a sudden, I, you know, I, I'm super satisfied with my dive watches. I've got this Fare, I've got my Pelagos. The last thing I need is a dive watch, but you go on, you go on Instagram, YouTube, Substack, everywhere, all the new Hydroconquest, new Hydroconquest, 'cause Longines is sending out these watches ahead of the release to all these influencers, and on the same day they're all releasing their videos about it.

32:12 All of a sudden you're like, "Oh, I need a, I need the Hydroconquest. I need, I need to sell something and buy it." David: Yeah. But JD: it, it's that Red Bull effect, like- It w- where our preferences are so shaped by the branding and marketing apparatus that we are, you know, just swimming in that we don't even- Yeah … fully realize it. So I, I think, I would say to a lot of people just figure out what's authentically you. Yeah. What do you actually like? What works with your lifestyle? Some people, you know, a dress watch, that wouldn't really work with their lifestyle 'cause they're, um, you know, they're contractors or something. David: Yeah. JD: But you might have watched all their content and be like, "I need a dress watch." It's like, but you'll never wear it.

32:52 You won't really like it. I, I work in a, a kind of a f- you know, semi-formal office environment with a lot of financial advisors and, and wealth advisors, so I wear a suit jacket a lot. I could wear a dress watch. It would blend in with my lifestyle, you know? David: Yeah. JD: Uh, I have a small child. The dive watch fits in great with that because I can wear it to work and then I can, you know, make a… I can switch the bezel to be like, "Oh, my, my daughter went to sleep 10 minutes ago," so I can track how long she's been asleep. Right. I do this every day, you know? It fits my lifestyle. So, you know, just think through your lifestyle and your actual preferences and just try to separate the two of, like, what's really truly authentically my lifestyle and my interests and my preferences, and what is, like, maybe a little bit too much of the zeitgeist- David: Yeah JD: shaping me.

33:41 And then expand that beyond watches and just think about that generally in your life and you'll- Yeah … kind of notice things like that everywhere. David: I think there is another column. It's the anti-zeitgeist column. Like, stop drinking the Kool-Aid, people. JD: Yeah, yeah, yeah. There's guys like you, David, who work in marketing and, and all this thing. David: It's all, it's all our fault. Yeah. It's all the marketing industry has done this crazy psychological mind tricks to everybody. JD: But- Yeah, it's great. We all do it. David: Well, JD Tyler, thank you for being with us. You are a total rock star, and I appreciate you sharing your wisdom. JD: Thank you, David. This, this was immensely fun.

34:24 David: And that wraps up another episode of Watch Smarts. Listen, if you love this show, if you love watches, subscribe, download, leave us a rating or review on your favorite podcast platform, and check out all the free resources waiting for you at watchsmarts.com.